Free senior care guidance for Indianapolis-area families. No cost to you, ever.
Call (463) 208-0977
Indy Senior AdvisorPeople • Places • Possibilities

Best Choice Home Care: Medicare Home Health Ratings in Indianapolis, IN

Best Choice Home Care is a Medicare-certified home health agency in Indianapolis, IN: 3.5 of 5 stars for quality of patient care and 4 of 5 on the patient…

Home›In-Home Care›Home health agencies›Best Choice Home Care

Best Choice Home Care is a Medicare-certified home health agency based at 5701 Elmwood Ave Ste N in Indianapolis, IN 46203. Medicare first certified it in 2005, 21 years ago. Medicare rates its quality of patient care at 3.5 out of 5 stars, above the Indiana average of 3. Its strongest result against the Indiana average is flu shot status checked; its weakest is got better at taking medicines correctly.

★★★½☆3.5 / 5Quality of patient care
★★★★☆4 / 5Patient survey
55Indianapolis-area ZIP codes served
2005Medicare-certified since

What is Best Choice Home Care's Medicare record?

AgencyBest Choice Home Care
Address5701 Elmwood Ave Ste N, Indianapolis, IN 46203
Phone(317) 632-1500
Medicare provider number (CCN)157560
OwnershipProprietary
Medicare-certified since02/15/2005

How does Best Choice Home Care score on Medicare's quality measures?

Medicare publishes 11 patient-outcome and process measures for Best Choice Home Care. It is better than the Indiana average on 3 and worse on 5.

MeasureBest Choice Home CareIndiana averageU.S. averagevs. Indiana
Started care on time100%96.6%96.6%Better
Got better at walking or moving around85.4%88.5%88.6%Worse
Got better at getting in and out of bed91.1%90.4%89.8%About the same
Got better at bathing87.3%90.5%90.7%Worse
Breathing improved86.4%91.7%91.5%Worse
Got better at taking medicines correctly75.7%88.4%88.3%Worse
Medication issues addressed on time99.2%96.1%94.4%Better
Flu shot status checked74.8%63.4%63.3%Better
Met expected function at discharge73.3%75.8%71.7%About the same
Falls with major injury (lower is better)2.8%1.1%0.9%Worse
New or worsened pressure ulcers (lower is better)0.2%0.3%0.2%About the same

Where it stands out: flu shot status checked, started care on time and medication issues addressed on time.

Where it trails: got better at taking medicines correctly, breathing improved and got better at bathing.

What do patients say about Best Choice Home Care?

81% of surveyed patients said they would definitely recommend Best Choice Home Care, based on 104 completed surveys. The Indiana average is 79%.

Survey questionBest Choice Home CareIndiana averageU.S. averagevs. Indiana
Team gave care in a professional way93%89%89%Better
Team communicated well91%87%86%Better
Team discussed medicines, pain and home safety74%81%82%Worse
Rated the agency 9 or 10 out of 1090%85%85%Better
Would definitely recommend the agency81%79%79%About the same

Do Best Choice Home Care's patients end up back in the hospital?

Medicare rates Best Choice Home Care better than the national rate on: patients who went home and stayed home after care ended.

MeasureMedicare's categoryRisk-adjusted rate
Patients who went home and stayed home after care endedBetter Than National Rate89.7%
Preventable hospital readmissions in the 30 days after careSame As National Rate4.5%
Preventable hospital stays during careSame As National Rate10.4%

Which home health services does Best Choice Home Care provide, and which does it not?

Best Choice Home Care reports offering skilled nursing, physical therapy, occupational therapy and speech therapy. It does not report offering medical social work and home health aide.

ServiceOffered by Best Choice Home Care?
Skilled nursingYes
Physical therapyYes
Occupational therapyYes
Speech therapyYes
Medical social workNo
Home health aideNo
Round-the-clock or shift careNo. Home health is visits, not shifts.
Housekeeping, meals and errands on their ownNo. Medicare does not cover them unless tied to skilled care.
Long-term help with bathing and dressingNo. That is non-medical home care, which families usually arrange and pay for separately.

Which Indianapolis-area ZIP codes does Best Choice Home Care serve?

Best Choice Home Care tells Medicare it serves 55 ZIP codes in Indianapolis and Marion, Hamilton, Hendricks, Johnson, Boone and Hancock counties, out of 63 in total.

  • 46032
  • 46033
  • 46037
  • 46038
  • 46040
  • 46052
  • 46055
  • 46060
  • 46062
  • 46074
  • 46077
  • 46107
  • 46118
  • 46122
  • 46123
  • 46131
  • 46140
  • 46142
  • 46143
  • 46163
  • 46168
  • 46184
  • 46201
  • 46202
  • 46203
  • 46205
  • 46208
  • 46214
  • 46216
  • 46217
  • 46218
  • 46219
  • 46220
  • 46221
  • 46222
  • 46224
  • 46225
  • 46226
  • 46227
  • 46229
  • 46231
  • 46234
  • 46235
  • 46236
  • 46237
  • 46239
  • 46240
  • 46241
  • 46250
  • 46254
  • 46256
  • 46259
  • 46260
  • 46268
  • 46278

A ZIP on this list means the agency accepts referrals there. It does not promise a nurse is available this week, so confirm your address when you call.

What should you ask Best Choice Home Care before starting care?

Ask who sorts out the medication list

75.7% of patients got better at taking their medicines correctly (Indiana average 88.4%). Ask whether a nurse reconciles every prescription at the first visit and who sets up the pill organizer.

Ask about breathing and oxygen management

86.4% of patients had less shortness of breath by the end of care (Indiana average 91.7%). If the diagnosis is COPD or heart failure, ask how the nurse monitors breathing between visits.

Ask who helps with bathing, and how often

87.3% of patients improved at bathing (Indiana average 90.5%). Ask whether a home health aide is part of the plan or whether bathing help is left to the family.

Ask whether your plan treats it as in-network

Original Medicare pays any certified agency. Medicare Advantage plans use networks, and an out-of-network agency can mean a denied claim. Give them the exact plan name on the card.

Which other home health agencies serve Indianapolis, IN?

These Medicare-certified agencies are also based in or near Indianapolis.

All Medicare-certified home health agencies in Indianapolis and Marion, Hamilton, Hendricks, Johnson, Boone and Hancock counties

Last verified: November 2026, against the Medicare provider data release dated 2026-09-21.

Common questions

Is Best Choice Home Care Medicare-certified?

Yes. Best Choice Home Care is certified by Medicare under provider number 157560 and has been since 2005. Original Medicare pays certified agencies directly for covered home health care.

What is Best Choice Home Care's Medicare star rating?

3.5 out of 5 for quality of patient care. The Indiana average is 3. Its patient survey rating is 4 out of 5.

Does Best Choice Home Care provide physical therapy at home?

Yes, it reports offering physical therapy to Medicare. It also reports skilled nursing, occupational therapy and speech therapy.

Not sure where to start?

Answer five questions and a local advisor will come back with senior care options in Avon that actually fit your situation and budget. It is free, and there is no obligation.

Find care options
Find Facilities Near You